Dories tells us this cake is big and beautiful and I would like to add…”spectacular” as some of my tasters described it….and also “11/10”, and “Out Of This World”. 😂
This is a show stopper, no doubt about it and when you have an ice cream loving family as I do, this hits the mark on every level!…all seven of them in this case!
There is nothing hard about making this, although it does take time. You need to make it a day ahead of time chilling each layer, and then also chilling the whole thing at least five hours, or overnight.
So here is the scoop…literally 😂
- The crust is made from crushed graham crackers, melted butter, and chopped peanuts
- Next layer, softened pint of premium ice cream. Dorie suggests coffee flavored. I went with Ben and Jerry’s Coffee and Toffee Bits
- Next layer, half of the homemade fudge we made from chocolate, heavy cream, sugar, and corn syrup..next time I need to split this in half better haha!
- Next up…another pint of softened premium ice cream…Dorie suggested vanilla and chocolate for these last two…I went chocolate chip and just split the regular container for each
- Next…a layer of peanut butter fluff filling…wow was that tasty!…made up chunky peanut butter, marshmallow cream, and a little milk.
- Last layer of ice cream…I finished up the chocolate chip
- Top it with the last half of the homemade fudge.
I stopped there because unfortunately we weren’t able to eat this big spectacular cake at a gathering and had to send it out in pieces to share…(and it made it without melting!) There would be one more layer of toasted marshmallows on top helping to give the cake its “s’mores” title. In all honesty…it didn’t need the extra marshmallows at all. We didn’t miss them. I am sure it would add to the look of the cake, but flavor wise, not necessary.
This is a cake that will be made again and again in my family. We absolutely loved it…for the small individual parts, but also in the grand scheme and the way the flavors all played together. Everyone thought this was one of the best things I have made in the group over the years.
Totally a keeper!